D.A. Charles Rosselini overcomes Erin principle objections to dating her boss and a mayoral candidate, but she backs down after Nicky tricks them into a Valentine’s date. Jamie dislikes the commercial fake romance, like grandpa, as it makes bachelors feel all the lonelier. A rich, divorced couple reports their daughter Chloe kidnapped for a diamond ransom, but after the delivery goes wrong it turns out that was staged with her boyfriend, who is alas found murdered by their accomplice, a drug dealer. Frank informally motivates a lazy detective to reconsider the ‘open and shut’ case against his cleaner Inez’s robbery-accused cousin.
Paige plays Patricia Ryan, a detective assigned to investigate a robbery.